In a recent void disposition case concerning a Trustee in Bankruptcy’s entitlement to claim compensation from the recipient for loss arising out of a breach of trust, the Court of Appeal (Ahmed and others v Ingram and another  EWCA Civ 519) has upheld the decision of the court below. The latter determined in the Joint Trustees’ favour an application under Section 284 of the Insolvency Act 1986 relating to transfers of minority shareholdings in three companies made, firstly, by the Debtor to his brother and, later, transfers by the Debtor’s brother to their sisters.
The brief facts are as follows:
The Bankruptcy Petition was presented against the Debtor on 23 January 2007, the transfer of shares by the Debtor to his brother took place after presentation of the Petition on 6 June 2007, and a Bankruptcy Order was subsequently made against the Debtor on 21 April 2009. The exact date(s) of the transfers from the Debtor’s brother to their sisters is not known but it was agreed to have been sometime between 2008 and 30 June 2009 from the public records available.
The shares were eventually re-transferred back to the Joint Trustees by the Debtor’s brother and sister but their value had fallen in the intervening period. The Joint Trustees claimed not only that the transfers of the shares were void but also sought compensation for the diminution in value between the initial transfer date of 6 June 2007 and the date of the transfer back on 27 February 2015.
At first instance, Mrs Justice Proudman, sitting in the High Court of Justice (Ingram v Ahmed  EWHC 1536 (Ch)) upheld the Joint Trustees’ application and determined that the transfers were void and that the Debtor’s brother and sisters were liable to pay to the Joint Trustees the diminution in value based upon a fair value of the shares at the relevant dates as opposed to market value.
The Court of Appeal determined the following issues: –
The issues decided in this case may be affected by the implementation of Section 291A of the Insolvency Act 1986 as the Official Receiver is now appointed First Trustee in Bankruptcy from the date of the Bankruptcy Order, so that in future cases the date of breach is likely to be the date of the Bankruptcy Order (as the date of appointment).
This is a decision of note for Trustees in Bankruptcy and Debtors alike in void disposition cases as it highlights an additional entitlement of the officeholder to claim compensation from the recipient for loss suffered to the Bankruptcy Estate where there has been a breach of trust.
If you are looking to bring or defend a claim of this nature and require some advice, then do please get in touch with us on 020 7353 1000 and ask to be put through to one of our specialists in Personal Insolvency. Alternatively, email email@example.com with your contact details and we will arrange for you to be called back.Back to news
We are pleased to announce the opening of our new South of England office in Portsmouth today. Welcome to Nick and Jackie!17th Sep 2018 15:22:31
Two new articles on our website on prohibited company names (https://t.co/9T2sxhR575) and Carillion (https://t.co/xmrjHABirP)15th Jun 2018 16:01:06
"Specialist insolvency boutique Isadore Goldman is ‘the standout firm for contentious insolvency matters’ "